top of page

If Everyone is Niche, Who is Mainstream?

Nikita Dabral
3 hours ago
3 min read

Somewhere along the way, convenience became uncool. We spend hundreds upgrading to phones with professional-quality cameras, yet insist on bringing a separate digital camera from 2007 on every night out. We celebrated the freedom of wireless earphones, only to decide that AirPods were out and dangling white wires were back in. Despite being able to order practically anything to our doorstep by tomorrow afternoon, we'd happily spend twice as much on a second-hand leather jacket with a questionable past and an even more questionable price tag.


The harder something is to find, the more desirable it becomes. Why buy a perfectly good dress online when you could spend your Saturday rummaging through racks of discarded clothing instead in a local charity or vintage shop? A few hours later, you emerge victorious with a vintage slip dress that looks suspiciously like something from your grandmother's wardrobe. Suddenly, the worn-out fabric is kind of cool, the awkward fit is very Kate Moss in the '90s, and you've already imagined three outfits to justify buying it.


Credits: British Vogue
Credits: British Vogue

There's a certain smug satisfaction in being asked where something is from and getting to reply, "Oh, I thrifted it." It's not something you can find with a quick Google search, and no, unfortunately, you can't get the same one. Half the satisfaction is knowing you discovered it yourself. The other half? Getting to tell people about it.

Whether it's any better than something brand new is almost beside the point, what matters is what finding it says about you. A vintage jacket suggests patience, discernment and knowledge of places that haven't reached everyone else's Pinterest boards. The same jacket hanging in H&M might not earn a second glance. Apparently, knowing where to shop has become almost as important as knowing what looks good.


Except even individuality now seems to come with a dress code. Take the rise of the so-called ‘mob wife’, ‘blokette’ and ‘office siren’ aesthetics. Somehow, dressing like a mafia boss's third wife, a football fan with a fondness for miniskirts or a corporate femme fatale became three entirely distinct fashion aesthetics. An outfit that starts in a niche corner of the internet can end up on everyone's For You Page before its original wearer has had time to wash it. What might once have been someone's wonderfully peculiar way of dressing suddenly has a name, a Pinterest board and approximately seventeen TikTok tutorials explaining how to recreate it. The internet doesn't just popularise personal style anymore, it turns it into a ready-made identity, complete with instructions on how to buy your way into it.


Credits: Pinterest
Credits: Pinterest

Fashion brands have caught on, too. The charm of Jane Birkin's famously overstuffed, personalised handbag was that it looked like a bag that had actually been lived in. Fast-forward a few decades, and we're buying bag charms, silk scarves and carefully selected trinkets to recreate that same sense of spontaneity. What once happened naturally is now carefully curated. Even looking effortlessly individual now comes with a price tag.


 Credits: CBC Arts
 Credits: CBC Arts

Of course, the desire to stand out while still fitting in is nothing new. Over a century ago, sociologist Georg Simmel described fashion as a tension between imitation and differentiation: we dress to belong, but also to stand apart. So, social media hasn't invented that contradiction, it's simply accelerated it. The Adidas Sambas we once admired on Bella Hadid became less exciting when they started appearing on every second person in the library. The shoes haven't changed, nor has whatever made us like them in the first place. What disappeared was the suggestion that wearing them meant we were ahead of everyone else.


Credits: Harper’s BAZAAR
Credits: Harper’s BAZAAR

I'll admit, I'm hardly innocent. I've been guilty of finding something less interesting the moment I discover it's from H&M, or feeling a little too pleased when someone compliments a thrifted find. I'm hardly the only one, either. Being niche, it turns out, is a rather popular ambition.


A good outfit doesn't become a bad one because someone else thought of it too. Somewhere along the way, we’ve confused having good taste with having taste nobody else has. And if liking something depends on nobody else liking it, perhaps it was never quite the clothes we were interested in. It was the distinction they gave us.


Comments


bottom of page