No, You Don’t Have to ‘Enjoy’ Reading

Just over a month ago, classicist Mary Beard stated that she cannot bear the phrase “I really love reading”’ on the Booker Prize 2026 shortlist livestream. Almost immediately, she was accused of elitism and pretentiousness. At the risk of also hastily being labelled as such, I’m inclined to agree.
Being a student of Modern History (and formerly English), it would be an understatement of immense magnitude to suggest that reading has played a formative role in my life. Even if I fall into the temptation of skipping a required seminar reading, or feel a slight sense of dread eyeing an 800-page history book that I’ll need for an impending essay, I can’t deny that reading has nurtured a quintessential part of myself. Something so much more than simply saying I ‘love’ reading. In fact, sometimes I despise it. Yet, it’s still an alluring and fruitful activity. Perhaps saying one ‘loves’ reading is just a matter of semiotics, or what one defines as ‘love’. Mary Beard seems to define it as a general, unthinking appreciation, much preferring the term ‘passion’. If it really is just a simple issue of wording, however, then the vitriol generated in response to her (quite tempered!) statement seems unwarranted.
‘I Really Love Reading’
There are certainly some books I’d hesitate to say I have ‘loved’. It’s hard to love experiencing very real horrors and conceptual existentialism alike condensed into a physical object inches from your face, condensed into communicable prose. Reading Stoning Mary and Waiting For Godot for an English module, for instance, was the furthest thing from a leisurely, joyous activity that I could imagine. Yet, such books are formative. They’ve changed how I look at the world just as much as the news and doomscrolling. Reading everything from children's novels to materialist philosophy has informed my understanding of how our world is constructed, and how I can interface with it. Such understanding, however inadequate and incomplete I admit it is – there is always something else to read about, to understand – stretches far beyond love; it is the closest I feel I could ever get to truth, if it even objectively exists.
To say one ‘loves reading’ also does great disservice to genre. Such a simple statement paints cosmic horror and Jacobean love sonnets as something equally enjoyable to everyone. If you ‘love reading’, you love the act itself. There is no room for individual taste in such a phrase. Not only does it fail to signal the intellectual engagement that accompanies reading, it also reduces the diversity of written works into an amalgamation which one will unquestionably engage with. Genre, as arbitrary as it can be, isn’t something to be thrown away: contextual classification matters in how we perceive written works, consciously and subconsciously. If one truly ‘loved reading’, then they would have no qualms about certain styles or modes, and simply gorge themselves on word after word without any personal preference. Is doing that truly ‘love’?
The Cult of ‘Having Read’
Reading outside of classwork is certainly enjoyable, and I don’t condemn reading for leisure or fun. In fact, there’s a certain subsection of readers that overcorrect in reading nothing for personal enjoyment, and refuse to engage in anything that is not already enshrined in the literary canon. Of course, this is problematic for several reasons, certainly not least by refusing to enshrine any disregarded work in a literary pantheon. It is undeniably snobbish to dismiss books that appeal to popular or ‘uneducated’ taste. That isn’t what Beard is arguing, however. Rather, the inverse: these books should not be tossed away or read uncritically. Even within disregarded genres one can find literary greatness – Lovecraft, as influential as he is now (while considering his many faults), was essentially unknown during his lifetime.

Yet, especially in some online circles there is a tendency to try and read so many books a year, a cultish obsession to have read, rather than engage thoroughly and deeply. Shortform content only makes this problem worse. Entire lists of books appear on Instagram reels or TikToks to serve both as recommendations (not necessarily bad in itself) and as subtle gloating over having read a sufficient amount. No one cares if you've read The Count of Monte Cristo, Don Quixote, and Crime and Punishment among countless others of books this year. What matters is if they meant something to you. To performatively ‘love reading’, rather than engage with books themselves, completely disregards why reading is fundamental to us, not only as students, but as human beings.




Comments